Hello tuburubu,
We quickly try to give people a place to do their own, up to the minute research as we do not have the time. Moreover we are not going to spend unknown hours of free calculations and research for technical people who often already have the answers and are just looking for a second source of supply or perhaps a second opinion. In addition, we often get misleading or incomplete information in the initial query.
This thread is a typical example.
The company in question recently purchased, installed and started a copper continuous cast line. My former company also has a Krupp-Hazelett continuous copper cast line for more than three decades and I know exactly what he wants. Why would we contact Hazlett to find out their present recommendation when the company who supplied their line is no doubt in almost daily contact with them and has the latest information they need right at their fingertips. We are also not going to get into a conflict with their supplier's latest recommendation.
Finally it is our experience that if we to do all the work gratis, we usually don't even get a thank you for it.
On the other hand, if we were to do nothing and just leave the question out there, hoping for an answer, it could takes months or even years to get that answer and that would be really terrible. Obviously the Forums would then cease to exist if that were to happen.
In this particular case it took some 9 weeks to get an answer from you. While we all appreciate your answer, do you think the initiator of the thread waited on pins and needles for 9 weeks for your posting? I very much doubt it. We also don't know who you are but we do know what company you are with and where you are located. You could be a Nobel Prize winning metallurgist and the world's foremost authority on continuously casting metals but here nobody knows that. We don't even know if the information you provided is actually up to date but it is still good information to know and we thank you for it.
WE are certainly not criticizing you but rather trying to get you to see this from the other side of the Forums. We also look forward to you actively posting technical information in future. I am sure you have a lot of valuable information that can benefit all of us.
Sincerely,
Peter J. Stewart-Hay
Principal
Stewart-Hay Associates
www.Stewart-Hay.com