Hello again bighead,
Both oil and water are OK but personally I prefer water because it is far less messy.
If you can obtain a constant input temperature of water, you can build your own system by using a proportional valve on the input and temperature sensing on the output water.
Another way is to contact your extruder and heat control panel manufacturer and see if you can buy an add-on control system for the screw. Hopefully there is an empty position for the controller in your existing heating control panel.
There are many other equipment manufacturers supporting the plastics industry with two of the more popular being Sterlco
www.sterlco.com/ and Mokon
www.mokon.com/ but you will have to contact them and evaluate them for yourself. I have used them both but not for screw cooling.
All equipment manufacturers will provide you with the details of their equipment including recommended flow rates and so on for both your screws. Armed with all this information, you can make your decision as to what you want to do.
See your screw manufacturer for the cooling assembly connected to your screws if you do not already have this. Ask them questions about the length of the cooling supply tube inside the screw in reference to the highest shearing point along the screw because both screws are quite different. See what they recommend for each screw.
Regards,
Peter J. Stewart-Hay
Principal
Stewart-Hay Associates
www.Stewart-Hay.com